“Grief Fuckfest”: A Review of All Of us Strangers

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Imagine walking into a cinema expecting a tender gay romance only to be greeted by what I can only describe as a grief fuckfest—quite literally. Misleading thirst trap trailers on TikTok had me thinking I was in for a steamy romance rooted hookup culture and happenstance romance. Instead, I spent two hours watching characters agonise over unresolved trauma while occasionally whispering into door frames.

All Of Us Strangers, directed by Andrew Haigh and starring Andrew Scott and Paul Mescal, follows a screenwriter named Adam who communes his dead parents while developing a relationship with his neighbour Harry. What the TikTok algorithm failed to mention was that this film is essentially about grief wearing misdirecting naughty underwear.

Let me be clear: I thought Claire Foy was going to be Andrew Scott’s long-lost sister based on the marketing. Instead, she plays his deceased mother, a spectral memory trapped in time alongside his father (Jamie Bell).

The central romance between Scott and Mescal does deliver some genuinely touching moments. Their chemistry is undeniable, and the intimate scenes are handled with care, astutely portraying queer courting and the hookup-to-dating pipeline. However, these moments of connection are always overshadowed by the weight of Adam’s grief, creating a viewing experience that’s more emotionally exhausting than satisfying.

If you’re expecting the kind of queer romance that leaves you feeling warm and hopeful, beatdown your expectations immediately.

This film teaches harsh lessons about not sharing your unfelt grief, as Adam’s inability to process his parents’ death ultimately sabotages his chance at happiness with Harry.

The film’s surreal approach to portraying grief is its strongest feature. The way Adam interacts with his parents—frozen in the 1980s when they died—creates a dreamlike quality that captures how memories can feel both immediate and distant. However, the pacing often drags, making the two-hour runtime feel much longer.

All Of Us Strangers is a film about murderous grieving—how unprocessed trauma can kill any chance at genuine connection. It’s beautifully acted and visually compelling, but it’s also relentlessly bleak. If you’re in the mood to confront the ghosts of your past while witnessing a romance that’s doomed from the start, this might be your perfect Friday night.

For everyone else, maybe stick to the thirst trap edits on TikTok. They’re less emotionally devastating.