A convenient fuck amongst competitors becomes a toe-curling entanglement.
New MM sports romance In Your Court by Australian author Kit Haley follows Matteo Russo, the first and only openly gay Australian professional tennis player, whose prickly rivalry with American superstar Miles Callahan turns into an increasingly complicated off-court tryst.
The setup is familiar: horny adonisoids, enemies-to-lovers, high-stakes secret sex, cocky fronts and culminating in queer joy.
It is a formula we clearly cannot get enough of, and Haley knows exactly how to serve it.
This novel is trying to make you horny, make you giddy about two men and then leave you very satisfied that you spent several hundred pages watching them fall in love. On those terms, it is enormously successful.
Haley’s tennis world is less glamorous than the fantasy would have you believe. Matteo’s career is shaped by money, rankings, travel, injury and the exhausting financial realities of being a professional player outside the very top tier. He talks about paying for coaches, physios, flights, accommodation, food and insurance himself, while players with more money can travel with whole teams. The contrast becomes part of the rivalry between Matteo and Miles rather than simple background decoration.
That attention to the unglamorous details gives the book more substance than its premise initially promises. These are not simply two hot men running around a tennis court waiting for an excuse to get their dicks wet. They are athletes whose bodies are their careers, whose financial circumstances shape their opportunities and whose professional lives are constantly being watched.
The sex, unsurprisingly, is plentiful and oh-so satiating.
Haley leans confidently into dominance, submission and the physical negotiation of desire. More importantly, sex is often doing character work. These men do not suddenly become emotionally articulate because they have fallen in love. For these two gay men, the sex is not a prize that arrives after their romance is neatly established. As in reality, it is the reverse, the romance between Matteo and Miles is insecure after a connection is formed through sex first. But what I loved in this book is how Haley shows sex can be used as a tool for the avoidant.
The book is very conscious of its genre. With meta references, to what Matteo is reading, a romance novel baring a strong resemblance to Heated Rivalry. This self-awareness is charming, although occasionally it draws attention to the formula of a romance novel a little too much. The prose leans a little contrived, making the novel less distinctive but it’s not necessarily a bad thing, it was still very enjoyable in its romance book-ness.
The other area where I wanted a little more was the central conflict. The book’s central professional pressure could occasionally have been pushed harder. Two players competing against each other should create an enormous ticking clock, particularly when their careers, public images and private relationship are colliding. The tension is there, but I sometimes wanted the tennis rivalry to bite a little deeper.
Still, Haley is particularly effective when dealing with the strange position of being publicly gay and owing a duty to the queer community.
Matteo is not simply an athlete who happens to be gay. He has become the gay tennis player, a title he resents. Journalists repeatedly want to turn his sexuality into the story, while he wants to be recognised for his tennis.
One of In Your Court‘s more interesting depiction is modern homophobia rather than cartoonish bigots. A quieter miasma surrounds Miles throughout: masculinity, reputation, sponsors, media narratives and the pressure to remain commercially palatable. Haley skilfully shows how queers endure homophobic whispers in professional lives and how explosive reaching a boiling point can be.
In Your Court does not change the game. It understands the game, plays it confidently and knows exactly which bits its audience has come to see.
It is hot. It is silly. It is occasionally very sweet. It is emotionally messy without becoming unbearable, and sexy without pretending that every sex scene is a literary breakthrough.
As Matteo himself puts it, once you start reading romance books, it is hard to stop. I suspect I will now have to read Heated Rivalry just to compare.
For lovers of Challengers, Heated Rivalry, queer sports romance and men who desperately need to communicate, In Your Court is an easy recommendation.
