An Older Dom Top for Young Fit Bottoms: An Interview

Gays are all too familiar with being pursued by older men when they come of age – or even earlier sometimes in this sad reality.

In the age of dating apps, this quest for tight fit young gays is even more prevalent.

Enter Adam*, a 64-year-old lawyer from Washington D.C., USA.

I was doing a cutesy little scroll through Grindr on a Wednesday evening while watching a movie after work, when an unexpected but not surprising Hey into older tops? slipped into my inbox.

Twas from a ‘Total dom top’ aged 55 – yes, he’s misrepresenting his age on Grindr – who eloquently shared he is a “total dom top for a younger fit bottom”.

Now, have I ever responded to this type of message before? No. But I have always had questions I wanted answered by these men.

And so, I started asking some of these questions to Adam before organising a sit-down interview to get to the bottom (preferably young and fit) of this ‘attraction’.

And so, on a rather sporadically stormy Thursday night in Amsterdam, I sat down with Adam to attempt to quell my confusion – and my apparent discomfort – with older men that pursue young gays.

—

I walked into his basement Airbnb, with a touch of apprehension and nerves. It was unclear whether he might still want to sleep with me or convince me of the pros of an older top. Keeping it urgent, I moved rightaway into getting him to describe his sexuality, desires and kinks.

He was blunt and direct. “I’m only attracted to younger guys and that goes anywhere from 18 to 32 [years of age]. I’m a total top. A dominant total top. The only thing I don’t do is bottom. I do everything else.”

In our initial chats on Grindr, Adam was averse to the word ‘kink’ and ensured I refer to his selective attraction as a ‘preference’. I was initially confident in my use of the word ‘kink’ but admit now it may have been improperly used, though I still wanted to hear his need for the distinction.

“It’s not a kink, it’s a preference. Kink is a very specific thing that you want to do like slapping or spanking, shitting on someone, dominating someone or peeing on someone. But liking someone or someone’s age group is not a kink, it’s a preference,” he said with a definitive edge.

Point to Adam. I lost a little ground in what was becoming a battle of sexual wit. But I steeled myself; the whole purpose of this interview was getting to the root of this attraction that he had. “What draws you to younger guys?”

Alas, he was uncertain or – if I was being cynical – dissembling.

“I don’t know. I wish I knew. I only get attracted to younger guys. I still like to have fun and party and dance – I feel like the younger guys help me do that better.

I don’t get physically attracted to older guys. I like people who are fit like myself and who are younger.

Generally, older guys are not fit and they don’t spend time taking care of themselves. There are exceptions to the rule. But, in general, you won’t find a 64-year-old with a six pack.”

He dismissed the suggestion of being attracted to older guys equally as fit as him, citing a pure attraction to the ‘younger face’.

“I don’t know what it is. You get attracted to what you get attracted to.

Like my friend, him and I are very sexually compatible. But, he likes taller guys. That’s not a kink, that’s a preference, the same way that I like younger guys, okay?”

Dissatisfied with this answer I ventured into asking about the origins of this attraction.

“I started having sex when I was 25, he was 19. I was attracted to him and he wanted to have sex with me and so we did. We were in school together, I was a graduate student and he was an undergraduate.”

He glossed past any deeper meaning and admitted an attraction to younger guys at his coming out at at 35-years-old.

With his beginnings offering no insight, I moved into whether Adam was consistent in his practice. “So the whole time you have been having sex, it has been with younger guys; have you ever tried with someone your age?”

“I tried with a 37-year-old six months ago. I had fun but I wouldn’t do it again. He only told me he was 37 after we had sex. He didn’t look 37 and so if they look younger I will still be attracted to them.

But generally, if someone is 38-40 [on the apps] I won’t even speak to them.”

I had hoped to use stories of his past experiences to grasp onto some unexpected description or feature. But I still had to press further for the basis of this adamant preference, pushing Adam to really unpack the qualities of the young. “Are there any experiences where you have had sex where the youth of a person really struck you?”

But in an inadvertant and outright denial of his preference, he replied, “The youth doesn’t strike me. The connection with the person is what counts. And I’m very picky.

I only like young, fit bottoms or versatiles. I’m not attracted to tops. I’m not attracted to over weight people. I’m very rarely attracted to African Americans. I’m not attracted to Asians.

It’s just attraction. You can’t pick and choose what you are attracted to, but those are the thing I am not attracted to. So, I’m very picky.”

So yet again, I was presented with more description of his preference but made no more ground on the why past his love of partying with the young.

I had my speculations that Adam’s preference might be an extension of his sexual position preference as a dominant top. But he didn’t see the correlation that I did and dismissed the idea that an age gap had any inherent power dynamics.

And with no change in demeanour, he said “Yes, I like to be in control of the sexual encounter. That has nothing to do with my preference. Being a top is what you do sexually. It is not the same.

My ultimate attraction is someone who is younger, but they’re not dependent on me. I don’t like being a sugar daddy. I like people who are independent of me, like my boyfriend. He doesn’t need me to support him, and that makes the relationship stronger.”

Then I started being a little naughty and threw leading questions that definitely cast my aspersions. “So, nothing about sexual inexperience or – on the extreme – virginity plays on your mind?”

“No. I mean I’ve been with virgin guys before but it hasn’t changed anything.

I didn’t ever seek it out. They just told me they were virgins. Of course it is a good feeling to fuck a virgin and be their first experience but I don’t seek it.

It’s good sex. They don’t know what to compare it to. So, whatever you do with them, it’s the first time and they like it because they’ve been fantasising about it for such a long time.”

As Adam had brought up through our interview and in precursory chats, he has a younger boyfriend. It struck me because of his glib approach to sex and relationships. I will admit that I was also intrigued to hear his perception of the boyfriend’s view and power within the relationship.

“He is 20. We met through Grindr. We started seeing each other once a week. Then, at one point he said, ‘Are we going to become boyfriends?’”

I thought what was the difference between us being friends with benefits and being boyfriends, but I think he wanted more, so we became boyfriends.

I’m his first relationship. He’s younger so he has a lot to learn about relationships. I kind of take a step back and let him take a step forward, not to pressure him.

I have to be patient, more patient than normal. There is a lot that he doesn’t understand. A relationship requires two people to give up themselves to each other.

He’s going to school, he’s got two jobs, he’s got a lot of friends, so he doesn’t have too much time for me. Whereas I expect more time from him, so I have to be patient with him.”

This did shock me a little as I will admit I did assume the dynamic in their relationship and I realised I was approaching the situation from a similar perspective as Adam’s family — What could their relationship possibly develop into?

“He told his mom and she is younger than me. He told his mother that I’m 50 and she had a heart attack—”

“A literal heart attack?”

“No, no, a joking heart attack. And she told him that he couldn’t date someone that old. He has told her [he is still dating me]. He tells her when he stays at my house because he lives with her, and she’s become more accepting.

I don’t blame her. I probably would have had the same reaction if I was in her shoes as a parent.

She doesn’t know me, she doesn’t know my background. She doesn’t know how much I care about him.”

After harping on the physical pleasure angle, I wanted to explore a more emotional side that Adam experiences and if he had ever received comments because of the age difference.

But, I was met with a blunt unreflective. “I don’t feel 64. I feel much younger and don’t ever feel a gap in connection.”

By this point, I felt hot across the face, feeling rather frustrated and flustered. I felt unconnected with Adam and still felt I didn’t understand a single aspect of him or see him truly sit with my questions. I started to wonder if Adam felt any of the criticisms that people – including me ardently apparently – throw at those who are solely attracted to younger people.

“My family criticises me all the time – well, not criticism but questioning why I am attracted to younger guys and saying that they can’t be a good partner.

I have questions about them too, so it’s fine. We don’t judge each other. They’re happy that I’m happy.

But when I told them about my boyfriend and that he’s 20, it wasn’t criticising; it was questioning for my benefit.”

“What is your response to comments?”

In what seemed like an attempt to absolve himself, Adam drove a sharp distinction between free will and attraction, relating his preference to an indomitable beast.

“It’s what I am attracted to. I can’t help it. I wish my choice was wider because I would able to sleep with different people.”

After dancing through similar questions for close to 40 minutes, stabbing Adam’s sexual psyche from all sorts of angles, I had saved the question I most anticipated for last. “How do you feel about the specific criticism that people who date younger are insecure about their age?”

A: I’m not insecure about my age at all. I’m very secure with about my age. I don’t look my age and I don’t feel my age. Age is just a number. It’s how you feel and how you look. I compare myself to other people who are 64 and I don’t look like them, and I certainly don’t feel my age. That’s the bottom line.

And, yet I didn’t make that final prod of confronting his lying about his age on Grindr.

—

This interview has irked me for weeks now. I still feel like I don’t have the answers I want.

I truly believe there is a why behind sexual attraction and preference, a past experience, a lesson learned or trauma leading you away from certain people.

I wanted to uncover that why for Adam and, by extension, other older men that pursue young gays.

Was it something more than I assumed it would be? Was there some other reason than vanity, insecurity or chasing lost youth?

But, being presented with the notion sexual attraction and preference is something that we are a victim to had me face my belief attraction is something we control.

I can only place my reasoning for this in my practice of emotional regulation, but we clearly need to uncover more of my reasoning if this belief rears it’s big ugly head in other interviews.

Adam seemed genuine and steadfast in his description of his attraction but I do have my reservations about his answers.

Like I said, if I was being cynical, I thought Adam a dissembling character.

But this process challenged my perception of kinks as sexual practice and raised the questions — is the act of choosing who you sleep with a kink in of itself? Or do we view an attraction to exclusively young people as a fetish?

I think I’ve been viewing pursuing younger guys as a part of sexual gratification, as if the chase is more important than the sex.

I am left ungratified, hungry for answers from the silver foxes and cougars out there.

Do I wish this was more of a contemplative interview? Yes.

Was I surprised it wasn’t as pondering when I reflected on the type of person I interviewed and remembered that I sourced the interview from Grindr? No.

— *A pseudonym used for this interview